poopreport : BMnewswire :

toilet charity drive

That which doesn't kill me may still make me vomit

Posted 02.25.2004 by Dave J
Here's an interesting tidbit: Our aversion to all things disgusting may be rooted in a hardwired self-defense mechanism in our brain.

Researchers showed visitors (40,000...I'm thinking that is definitely statistically significant) images of items, varying in degrees of disgusting, from a muddy football to a gaping, infected wound (the responses were measured using the Disgustometer, a remarkably complicated rating scheme of 1 to 5, with 1 being not disgusting and 5 being *BARF*). People tended to rate the football as least disgusting, while the wound and other bodily fluids ranked much higher.

While that's all interesting, I personally take umbrage with the closing line of the article: "There is also evidence that animals have a disgust response. They, like humans, tend to avoid each others' feces."
Well, I'm annoyed by this on a few levels. First though, who ever wrote that statement obviously never tried to raise a dog and a cat simultaneously. I swear to god, my dog had kitty litter on his nose everyday! Sure, the dog had issues, did I seek help? Heck no, I never had to clean out a litter box. We (my parents and I) eventually had to change his name to Sir Pooples.

Okay, so there's a bit of hyperbole in there; we did try to dissuade him from eating his "brother's" crap, but the fact that we had to encourage him to avoid it is proof enough to me that the closing line is a bunch of dung.

Also; Maybe they've got the whole thing backwards: They (the authors, that is) seem to be postulating that the disgust emotion will help steer us clear of "dangerous" things. They then go on to correlate the response in terms of sight, noting along the way that things that rank consistently higher in disgust-factor also smell worse (a clean wound vs. an infected wound. A muddy football vs. anything more odorous than a muddy football, yet still with the same general appearance, etc.) What they're trying to prove is that our ability to see disgusting things is all it takes to avoid disease!

Here's an example...let's say you're in a well-lit room with a tray of freshly baked brownies that smell, literally, like poo. Do you eat them just because they look harmless?
Now let's say you're in a pitch black room, and there's the oppressive stench of feces present. Do you stick around just because you don't see anything, or do you get the heck out of there?

Sight has nothing to do with it. If it did, then they should be able to provide the additional proof of hundreds of dead/dying/diseased blind people, who didn't know any better, and ate a turd. There are plenty of healthy, living sighted people walking around, and there's also a bunch of blind people around (they seem to always be driving around me whenever I'm on the road), but how many smell-impaired people do you know? See? We don't even have a WORD for people like that, because, they don't last...they eat a turd, and die*.

Aaagh!...I get so angry.

*- I, in fact, do know someone with no sense of smell, but she's a PhD, and lost it due to chemical exposure before OSHA. Nice lady, but a terrible cook...
Show some poop support, or make a poop retort.
Anonymous Coward -- 02.26.2004

I also know someone with no sense of smell. His girlfriend would always cook for him, and he would always pretend to enjoy it, even though smell contributes a lot to taste and therefore he couldn't taste much of anything.

But to your point, Dave J (and could you moderators make it any more confusing to tell between the two of you??): it's not that people don't use their sense of smell, or that the researchers deliberatly ignored it. It's that our sense of DISGUST seems to kick in when we see things that are threats to us. That's the point. That's why we enjoy the sight of our own poop/the smell of our own farts, but not others' -- because other people's poop carries foreign bacteria that can give us diseases. Whatever bacteria is in our poop is a disease we already have.

And yeah, the thing about animals is just dumb. In the wild, feces and urine is used for marking territory... that's why dogs sniff it.

Anonymous Coward -- 02.26.2004

I also know someone with no sense of smell. His girlfriend would always cook for him, and he would always pretend to enjoy it, even though smell contributes a lot to taste and therefore he couldn't taste much of anything.

But to your point, Dave J (and could you moderators make it any more confusing to tell between the two of you??): it's not that people don't use their sense of smell, or that the researchers deliberatly ignored it. It's that our sense of DISGUST seems to kick in when we see things that are threats to us. That's the point. That's why we enjoy the sight of our own poop/the smell of our own farts, but not others' -- because other people's poop carries foreign bacteria that can give us diseases. Whatever bacteria is in our poop is a disease we already have.

And yeah, the thing about animals is just dumb. In the wild, feces and urine is used for marking territory... that's why dogs sniff it.

Anonymous Coward -- 02.26.2004

Ty- I have to admit you've raised some excellent points. I also have to admit that there just seems to be some freak coincidence with guys named Dave...seems we have more than statistically we should at this site.

Thanks for taking the time to write!

Cheers,
Dave J

Anonymous Coward -- 02.26.2004

Ty- I have to admit you've raised some excellent points. I also have to admit that there just seems to be some freak coincidence with guys named Dave...seems we have more than statistically we should at this site.

Thanks for taking the time to write!

Cheers,
Dave J

Post new comment



Prove you're not a spambot: what bodily function is this site about? Four letters, begins with p...

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

*

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
20,000 character limit / Flood control: 60 seconds between comments and no more than 10 comments per hour

i poop and i vote

 


About PoopReport | Advertise! | The PoopReport Press Room | Report Your Poop | Contact Dave | Copyright 2000-2008 PoopReport.com