poopreport : Intellectual Crap :

The Silver Screen Is Getting Browner: An Analysis Of Poop In Film

Posted 02.14.2005 by The Big Wiper (2244)
Back in January '03, before I became an active PoopReporter, I was a lurker. And back then, it was the Movie Poop Scene Archives that especially caught my eye. I'm still partial to that section of this site, to the extent that over the past two years, I have contributed forty-six entries to the cause. Recently I decided to undertake a statistical analysis of our impressive offerings, utilizing IMDB.com to gather research on 230 of the 239 films currently featured on the site. (A handful of the archived films failed to come up on IMDB.) My goal: to uncover any trends in movie poop scene proliferation. (Click here to see the data table.)

There are four films from the sixties with archived poop scenes, seventeen from the seventies, 45 from the eighties, 81 from the nineties, and 83 from 2000 until today. Although its unlikely every poop scene from the past fifty years has been archived on PoopReport, I believe a very high percentage of them are, given the fact that scores of poopers have been sending in these reports over a three-year period.

I am quite a movie buff myself. I have a collection of over 125 films; and, as a writer, I've watched hundreds of classic films from the thirties, forties and fifties, paying close attention to dialogue and plotting. There are very likely no films from these earlier decades with poop scenes -- images of overt sexual acts or references, as well as bodily functions, were strictly prohibited during this period. Cultural mores and taboos, enforced at the time by the studios themselves but aided and abetted by organizations such as the Roman Catholic-inspired Legion Of Decency (founded in 1934 to "combat the making of immoral Hollywood movies") all but ensured poopless scripting.

But by the late fifties, the old studio system had begun to crumble; independent film producers had arrived upon the scene with more freedom of subject matter. The Legion Of Decency had moderated its position, and had ceased to exist altogether by 1975. So it's no coincidence that the earliest archived poop scene, in 1964's Dr. Strangelove, is from the sixties, when censorship standards had started to relax.

The late sixties ushered in the well-documented sexual revolution, accompanied by the communal Shamelessness of Hippie culture, best exemplified by the open peeing and pooping in the fields at Woodstock.

By the seventies, reflecting trends in the culture, images of more graphic sexuality were cropping up more frequently in scripts, along with particular bathroom functions. We have 17 movies archived from the seventies -- more than triple the number from the sixties. By the late seventies, films like Up In Smoke (Cheech & Chong, 1978) and More American Graffiti (1979) were drenched in counterculture terminology and attitudes towards both sexuality and bodily functions. In addition, John Waters' 1972 film Pink Flamingos went way over the top in depicting the transvestite Divine actually eating a piece of dogshit. (This was not faked or a special effect, as subsequent commentary about the making of the movie revealed. Divine, himself, was traumatized by what he had done, and worried that he would get sick -- although he supposedly didn't.)

The eighties features 45 archived movies -- once again nearly triple the number from the previous decade. By this decade, films featuring poop scenes had branched out into all genres. 1980's Baby-Ruth-in-the-swimming-pool scene from Caddyshack and the gym-teacher-on-the-pot scene from Porky's II: The Next Day, were played strictly for laughs. But Neil Simon's Brighton Beach Memoirs (1986), Das Boot (1981), and the Oscar-nominated Fame (1980) and Working Girl (1988) offered characters pooping at home or at the office, under unremarkable circumstances. In fact, it's worth noting here that Fame was a hip, enormously successful version of the old pristine (and poopless) forties and fifties M-G-M musical, complete with two scenes of students faking or taking serious dumps -- something Gene Kelly, Fred Astaire or Judy Garland would never have been caught dead doing.

There was a veritable explosion of poop scenes in the nineties; we have 81 films archived, nearly doubling the selection from the eighties. Poop scene depiction truly began to come of age in this decade -- some of these films were Oscar winners, including Clint Eastwood's Unforgiven (1992), featuring an outlaw gunned down while shitting in the outhouse; and Kevin Costner's Dances With Wolves (1990), in which two Union soldiers squat outside in the high grass near each other. Neither of these scenes was played for laughs, effectively conveying instead the tenuousness of less-settled periods in our country's history. Pulp Fiction and The Shawshank Redemption, both from 1994, were two more critically-acclaimed works with crucial scenes of #2 action not played for laughs, revolving around issues such as mob hits and prison escapes.

On the more frivolous side, 1999's American Pie continued the successful and time-honored tradition of working student shitting into a lightweight plot; while 1997's Austin Powers, with SNL alum Mike Myers, was the first installment of a franchise that has prominently featured fecal activity on the part of its broadly-drawn characters.

That brings us to the current decade, the first of the new millennium. It's interesting to note that there are already 83 films archived in the first five years of this decade, which surpasses the total from the nineties -- with five more years still remaining. If this trend continues and PoopReport keeps on truckin', there could be at least 160-plus entries by 2010.

Over 60% (140) of the archived poop scenes come from comedies. The remainder is divided equally among drama, action-adventure, and sci-fi/horror categories. My take on the preponderance of poop scenes in comedies versus other genres is that people are more comfortable when bathroom activity and bodily functions are played for laughs. 2002's Jackass: The Movie, Scary Movie 2 and 3, and National Lampoon's Van Wilder are all examples of the juvenile approach to the poop scene, depicting explosive diarrhea, surreptitiously-slipped laxatives, and dumps in inappropriate places at inopportune times. At the opposite end of the spectrum, three Oscar-nominated films -- The House of Sand and Fog (2003), The Life and Death of Peter Sellers, and Sideways (both from 2004) -- each depict characters pooping uneventfully as a normal part of life. That depiction now seems light-years removed from the Legion Of Decency heyday, when the very existence of bodily functions was never even acknowledged.

One other bit of trivia I found interesting: three actors in particular seem to have appeared in more poop scenes than any others so far (not counting sequels): Robin Williams has four, in Mrs. Doubtfire, One-Hour Photo, The Fisher King and Good Morning, Vietnam; while Jim Carrey (Dumb & Dumber, Me, Myself And Irene, and Bruce Almighty) and Tom Hanks (Castaway, Forrest Gump and The Terminal) offer up three apiece. So it's clear that poop scenes are certainly no detriment to an actor's career.

If you haven't perused our archives lately, why not scroll through the entries now? Or better yet, go to your favorite video store and rent one or more of these films -- and see for yourself how Hollywood has grown in its depiction of a basic fact of life for every single human being on this planet.

Dave (11589) -- 02.14.2005

Incidentally, I have about 12 more poop scenes sitting in my inbox waiting to get posted. But TBW is right... there can't be too many that we're missing.

Logjam (2417) -- 02.14.2005

Nice analysis, TBW. Will we know that we've finally arrived when the number starts falling off a bit. When do you project that might be?

On a related theme, a few years ago I noticed that nearly every movie I saw had a vomit scene, and that more recently those have begun to taper off. Those scenes often functioned to communicate how revolting a character had found some experience. Is there a similar role for the poop scene in a movie, and if so, what is it? You imply there is when you mention the poop scenes that are there for other than humor. How do they generally function to push the plot along?

The Big Wiper (2244) -- 02.14.2005

I don't see poop scenes tapering off. I believe we will see more realistic depiction of bodily functions as time goes on. Such depiction, though on the increase, is still finding its way. Bodily functions are, in fact, a part of life, but progress towards integrating them in a non-sensational manner into plots has been slow.

When poop scenes have been included in plots in a non-juvenile manner (such as in the movie 'American Splendor,' or 'The House Of Sand And Fog,') they have advanced the plot by not having the camera divert its eyes from a basic fact of life but facing it straight on.

In 'Sand And Fog,' the teenage son, holed up with his parents in the bathroom for a long time, must eventually poop and does so right next to his father, while his mother (in the nearby bathtub) averts her eyes.

This depiction has a two-fold purpose: it is a realistic take on what might happen to members of a family under those circumstances, and it actually ends up bonding the father and son in a subtle way.

It's shown as an ordinary circumstance, and the father and son (and mother) deal with it in a 'not-such-a big-deal' manner. So the viewer comes away with a very believable impression of this family unit.

I trust I have answered your question here.

Logjam (2417) -- 02.14.2005

"I trust I have answered your question here."

Yes, and in a most timely way. Thank you.

The Shit Volcano (3741) -- 02.14.2005

I think people are starting to open their minds to bathroom humor. We'll be seeing a lot more poop in the movies. Not to mention television.

The Baron von P... (21) -- 02.14.2005

Interesting little bit of history here:

At the turn of the 20th century, silent films were becoming a way to be entertained; 5 cents got you 30 minutes of silent motion picture (woo!). For a couple of decades, there was no 'ratings system' or anything like that, so the films that were shown in the early 1900's were, in essence, free to show what they wanted. Smutty films were not at all uncommon, and I wouldn't be the least bit suprised if at some point they showed a little poo action. Hollywood tends to 'forget' that this kind of film was shown at any point without restrictions, so you don't really hear about or see any of them anymore. The same people who pioneered the prohibition movement (those bastards) were most likely the ones that changed the way the movie industry operated.

Also, the theaters back then that showed the movies for 5 cents were nicknamed "Nickelodeans"

Anyway, that's all I have to say about that.

The Big Wiper (2244) -- 02.14.2005

Excellent input, Baron. You make a good point. In the very beginning guidelines could not possibly have existed. I'm sure the nickelodeons were viewed as a novelty only, and no one could have envisioned the mega-industry into which they would evolve.

DungDaddy (1370) -- 02.14.2005

Big Wiper. You are a true scholar. This is perhaps the best poop "report" I've seen. Superb and compelling analysis.

"My take on the preponderance of poop scenes in comedies versus other genres is that people are more comfortable when bathroom activity and bodily functions are played for laughs." You even use the word "genre". Using genre makes this Pullitzer material. I have to stop praising you now, or you will no longer take me seriously.

It has long been my belief that poop is vastly underrated in our society. Think about it: Poop is very important. If a person looses his ability to poop or has poop problems, his life can be ruined. Yet, as a topic of discussion or art, it is often considered taboo. Thats not right. Virtually every movie made has scenes of people eating. Why not deal with the other end -- if not just a little bit? Food, after all, is just embrionic shit.

As our society matures, intellectually and artistically, I believe poop related scenes in movies will increase.

The Big Wiper (2244) -- 02.14.2005

Thanks for the kind words, DungDaddy. I was hoping that this piece would generate the sort of intellectual exchange in which you just indulged.

Film is a reflection of our world--the tragedy, the comedy, the highs and lows. If we exclude bodily functions, pretending they don't exist, we necessarily give a false picture of the world in which we live.

There are people--some of whom who have briefly visited our site and left their freaked-out comments--who believe that all bodily functions are 'too much information,' indecent or shameful.

The basic thrust of PR is to advocate the opposite belief: that it is literally business as usual, no big deal and can even be a legitimate source of humor, camaraderie and bonding among certain people.

Hollywood almost always stays a bit behind the curve on cultural trends, waiting for the right signals to arrive from the mainstream media before they will venture depictions of any particular idea. The proliferation of poop scenes in the last two decades clearly indicates that the entire arena is moving into the mainstream of ideas and is no longer being isolated as a ludicrous or objectionable novelty.

wonderpance (576) -- 02.14.2005

excellent report, mr. wiper!

i think the fact that dr. strangelove is the earliest archived film with a poop scene is just more testament to the fact that stanley kubrick was a genius, and the greatest filmmaker of all time. he had poop/bathroom scenes in all his films to show the mundanity of real life, and that no matter what's going on or who you are, we're still all basically humans who have to do things like eat and poop.

will (not verified) -- 02.14.2005

As always, very well written ,TBW. I understand that Woodstock would have been a dream for anyone interested in pooping & likely urgent pooping.

I have not seen a good many of these movies, but I guess I have a treat in store, huh?

In The Bushes (111) -- 02.14.2005

This isn't the most necessary statement, but great report! I have been thinking about this ever since you first mentioned it, and have been looking forward to your analysis.

ChiefRunnyPoop (not verified) -- 02.14.2005

if the TV studios would feature more pooping on it's shows i guess that would mean more crappy TV to choose from.

Hole Digger (not verified) -- 02.14.2005

Baron, Nickelodeons were also more commonly available in big cities. A very small percentage of people actually saw a nickelodeon. It is a fallacy on the part of a cultural historian to classify an era or event by the actions in the urban areas or in the rural areas.

Ana Latentive (not verified) -- 02.14.2005

Great Review!

Here's a movie missing from the database:

Labyrinth of Passion (1982 - Spanish)

I haven't seen it, but it's descibed around the net in several places as having a poop scene. Here's one such description:

"One of the very few movies like this is Labyrinth of Passion, where a woman craps in her pants after using a laxative and you can actually see it on her legs."

From:

http://www.griot.net/house/toilet/

page 862

Baron von Pooptoven (not verified) -- 02.15.2005

I wouldn't doubt for a second that early movies were more prevailant in urban areas... after all, over half the population at the turn of the century was in urban areas (I think :) )

I really like history, and if there was more money to be made at it, I would get my degree in it.

Baron out

Baron von Pooptoven (not verified) -- 02.15.2005

Shit... I spelled "Nickelodeons" wrong... now I look like a tard.

The Big Wiper (2244) -- 02.15.2005

Ana Latentive: please submit your movie poop scene officially to Dave via the Movie Poop Scene Archives so he can post it there. Thanks.

Chris Rockwell (42) -- 02.15.2005

Amazing piece of work Big! I will be adding a few more to the list.

Daily Constitutional (not verified) -- 02.15.2005

Wonderful essay! The paragraph citing the current actors with high pooping credits was quite interesting. Each of the three actors have tackled comedy and drama, and have careers that seem to be immune to the one-flop-you're-out syndrome that more untried actors suffer. It's not surprising that the top three are popular and have range and don't rely on good looks or star power. There's a reason that Tom Cruise isn't on the poop list.

hakim ibn hara (not verified) -- 02.16.2005

All we are saying is Give Fece a Chance

liquidy_poo (63) -- 02.16.2005

It's always good to know that when I see TBW is the author of an article, I've got a good 10 to 15 minute read. Short reports usually aren't too good, and this one definitely qualifies as a good read. And I like nice long reads.

Good research, good information, just good everything! I can only hope that I become as good a writer as you, TBW.

The Big Wiper (2244) -- 02.17.2005

Daily Constitutional: I couldn't agree more with your opinion of Tom Cruise. He's always trying way too hard to win an Oscar.

liquidy: appreciate your kind comments. If your goal in life is to be a writer, the best advice I can give you is to write, write, write. And then write some more. I've finally got the agent, editor and book contract I've always wanted, but it's taken many years.

Crappaccino (not verified) -- 03.10.2005

Don't forget the scene in "Jurassic Park" when the T-Rex at the guy straight off the crapper with his pants around his ankles (the guy, not T)

dump leaver (not verified) -- 03.17.2005

this has even become apparent in children's movies as well. I took my 2 kids to see "Robots" last week when it opened, and it also has a scene in which to robots interrupt a third robot dropping a deuce, presumably nuts and bolts.
P.S. why do people call it "taking a dump" when you are actually leaving one?

Oral Excrement (not verified) -- 06.23.2005

Does anyone remember the incredible scatological scene in 'Trainspotting' wherin one of the characters, high on heroin, craps the bed and tries to sneak out with the messy bedsheets past the family of his girlfriend at the breakfast table? The mother thinks he's just being kind, helping with the laundry and all, and attempts to wrestle the soiled sheet from him. They struggle over the sheet, finally snapping it open and covering the enyire dining family with a nice chunky layer of first-rate shit. I nearly died laughing.

Post new comment



Prove you're not a spambot: what bodily function is this site about? Four letters, begins with p...

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

*

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
20,000 character limit / Flood control: 60 seconds between comments and no more than 10 comments per hour

i poop and i vote

 


About PoopReport | Advertise! | The PoopReport Press Room | Report Your Poop | Contact Dave | Copyright 2000-2008 PoopReport.com